The foundation created to protect Robert Indiana's legacy has listed the artist's longtime home on Vinalhaven, Maine, for sale, even though his will called for the property to become a public art space.
Known as the Star of Hope, the 19th-century former Odd Fellows lodge is priced at $1.4 million. A second nearby building connected to Indiana is also on the market for $210,000.
Indiana, celebrated worldwide for his LOVE series, lived on the island from 1978 until his death in 2018. In his estate plans, he asked that the home be restored to museum quality and used for exhibitions, classes, lectures, and the preservation of his collection.
The Star of Hope Foundation says the sale would allow it to shift from property management to direct support for artists and arts groups in Maine. Foundation leaders describe the move as a way to turn real estate into philanthropic resources for the local creative community.
The decision has prompted debate among those familiar with Indiana's intentions, while others on Vinalhaven see the sale as a chance for the building to find new life. The property has already seen some restoration work, including roof, window, and door repairs, but it still requires significant attention.
As the future of the landmark is reconsidered, the outcome could shape how artist estates balance preservation, access, and community investment in the years ahead.
